| Wednesday, August 15th, 2007 | Emily Halevy | CWK Producer |
“When a young person diets on their own and they're not sure how to balance their food plan, they may broadly cut out a whole food group and not realize that they are cutting out essential nutrients, essential energy.”
– Page Love, registered dietician.
Each year millions of Americans try to improve their health and appearance by going on a diet -- at a cost of $40 billion dollars a year. Some of those dieters are kids, but often their efforts to lose weight produce exactly the opposite result.
Kelly Steed, 17, wanted to get in shape for the summer, so she went on The South Beach Diet.
“For the first phase, which is 14 days I think, you eat hardly any carbs and hardly any sugar, and no dairy products or anything like that,” says Kelly.
According to a new study from Canada, 13 percent of young girls are on a diet to lose weight, and many of them end up gaining weight. Experts say the problem is two-fold.
“When a young person diets on their own and they’re not sure how to balance their food plan, they may broadly cut out a whole food group and not realize that they are cutting out essential nutrients, essential energy,” says Page Love, registered dietician.
The second problem, says Love, is that too often, they starve themselves all day long.
“And we’re so hungry because of the energy void that we’ve built all day that the potential for overeating or the potential for binge eating is much greater,” says Love.
Experts say that especially for kids, diets often fail and can be unhealthy.
“Children are growing. You don’t want to inhibit their diet so much that it interferes with their ability to grow normally and grow healthfully. So imposing crazy diets on them and real strict diets where they are not allowed to have any of the things that they normally would like to have, that’s obviously unhealthy for them, too,” says Dr. Lonny Horowitz, M.D.
What works best, Horowitz says, is healthy eating and regular exercise.
Kelly lost 15 pounds on her diet, but gained half of it back. She says cutting back on carbohydrates isn’t enough by itself. Low-carb diets have an added risk for teenage girls: the high protein intake can cause a loss of bone density over time, potentially increasing the risk of osteoporosis as women age.
“I think that it’s everything combined. You have to work out and eat healthy and just all of it,” Kelly says.