| Wednesday, May 31st, 2006 | Kristen DiPaolo | CWK Network |
“To strive for something which is a bit idealized is not necessarily a bad thing, so long as it’s not so idealized that it makes people feel terrible about themselves. ”
– Bradd Shore, Ph.D. Director, Emory Center for Myth and Ritual in American Life
Today’s TV parents are a far cry from June and Ward Cleaver.
Tony Soprano is a criminal, Homer Simpson abuses his son, and Peggy Bundy neglects her children.
Experts say dysfunctional families on television can create problems for real families.
“It sort of validates the idea of dysfunctional relationships,” says Bradd Shore, the director of the Emory Center for Myth and Ritual in American life. “Rather than saying ‘maybe there’s a way that we can learn to sort of live better together,’ it really says, ‘Well, everybody’s like this.’”
He says the Jerry Springer Show is the extreme example of family dysfunction.
“And people who watch [those programs] look and say, ‘my family may be a problem, but it’s not that screwed up,’” says Dr. Shore.
He says families from the old days of television may have been too ideal, or too perfect - but they served a purpose. “To strive for something which is a bit idealized is not necessarily a bad thing,” says Shore, “so long as it’s not so idealized that it makes people feel terrible about themselves.”
He says one thing the Cleavers did right was letting their kids simply be kids.
“The notion of hyperactive is used about kids,” says Shore, “but it’s also true about families. Families are sort of groomed to be kind of constantly activity-oriented, where the activities are often professionalized. They are at lessons, or they have personal trainers for the kids and that sort of thing. And I think that sometimes we forget just to let the kids play.”